Fiction Reviews
Sep. 13th, 2006 09:45 amI'm just gonna vent.
I sent somebody a critical review of their fiction. It was a good story, but needed work like every fic does. So I reviewed it and sent it back, being 100% honest and trying to be helpful. Being a lot less harsh than the publishers who have rejected my crap.
She emailed me back stating that I hurt her feelings.
WTF? Grow up, I want to slap her. It's a good start, I told her that repeatedly. It just needs work on the plot structure and character developments. You can't have a flat character as a lead. It just doesn't go anywhere. Basic story telling elements. She had been a good friend up to this point, now I get a weird vibe from the whole thing. If you expect all empty fluffy praise for your work you're never going to grow as an author. I was trying to help.
I realise that not everyone writes on the same level, or is capable of the same output, but I never meant to offend with my review.
I fucking *hate* upsetting people.
I sent somebody a critical review of their fiction. It was a good story, but needed work like every fic does. So I reviewed it and sent it back, being 100% honest and trying to be helpful. Being a lot less harsh than the publishers who have rejected my crap.
She emailed me back stating that I hurt her feelings.
WTF? Grow up, I want to slap her. It's a good start, I told her that repeatedly. It just needs work on the plot structure and character developments. You can't have a flat character as a lead. It just doesn't go anywhere. Basic story telling elements. She had been a good friend up to this point, now I get a weird vibe from the whole thing. If you expect all empty fluffy praise for your work you're never going to grow as an author. I was trying to help.
I realise that not everyone writes on the same level, or is capable of the same output, but I never meant to offend with my review.
I fucking *hate* upsetting people.